Skip to content
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Harbor Point Blog

If the Blacksmith Has a Countless Detractors, I Stand as One of Them.

The moment I discovered that Clint from the beloved farming sim was revealed as one of the two marriage candidates in the forthcoming version 1.7, I yelled incredulously, “That incel?!” I was fixated for the rest of the evening — should Clint possess a million haters (and he does), count me among their ranks; were he to have no enemies, I have left the world of the living. However, with some reflection, I now realize that maybe that’s exactly the point — no resident in greater need of redemption than Clint.

The Root of the Dislike

Clint has attracted significant criticism over the years, primarily because of his fixation on Emily, a fellow marriage candidate. In one of his early cutscenes, he asks the player about how to talk to women, proceeds to act incredibly awkwardly in front of Emily, as she serves him in the saloon, then laments to the player that he’s “doomed.” He often appears pessimistic, needy, and borderline creepy — to many, he feels like a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at even the slightest perceived rejection.

A Widespread Response

The response to this part of the 1.7 update was far from unique. Players have voiced a host of grievances, disappointment over other characters who could have been picked instead, and countless memes following the announcement. A commentator wrote, “Picture finishing the worst shift of your life and finding out Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Glimmer of Hope

Nevertheless, some discussion about this hasn’t been so bleak and — as much as I hate to admit it — has raised some valid arguments. Several players have compared the idea of Clint’s redemption to that of Haley. She is notoriously rude when you first meet her, but softens over time through friendship, a journey some have referred to as “improving Haley to make her better as a person.” Clint shares a lot of that same potential, but with a crucial distinction: he gives a lot of players the ick.

Screenshot: ConcernedApe

The Uneasy Feeling

For me, Haley’s initial unpleasantness more palatable than Clint’s unrequited fixation with a woman who doesn’t reciprocate, and numerous fans appear to share the same. It's difficult to pinpoint exactly the reason — maybe it's simply a situation many fans can relate to, giving them a stronger gut response to Clint. This discomfort inherent to Clint undeniably presents an additional challenge in him being seen as an desirable marriage candidate, but that’s arguably yet another reason the character desperately needs redemption.

A Trace of Understanding

I will admit that, as many times as I’ve complained about how much Clint needs to stop being weird, he does inspire some level of sympathy. Maybe not during the notorious scene in the bushes, but in general, he does seem like a melancholy, isolated man. A fan wrote, “He is a man yearning for someone who will choose him back, and that is what being romanceable offers him.”

A Place for Growth

The blacksmith's upcoming romance path might not appeal to all types of Stardew Valley player, but it does have its place. However skeptical I am that I could ever viewing him a potential husband, the game's creator is a skilled storyteller with a knack for adding layers to every character in Pelican Town. Similar to past updates, the 1.7 update appears as a sizable new addition with a lot of love behind it, and his character arc is unlikely to be handled carelessly. Perhaps through this new chance at love, fans can finally put their hate for Clint and redirect it where it truly belongs — on Pierre.

Written by

Randy Hubbard

A coastal lifestyle writer with a passion for community storytelling and sustainable living practices.

Harbor Point Blog

Type to search articles.